What malcolm gladwell gets wrong about the relative. Its a beautiful example of a selffulfilling prophecy. The story of success 2008, malcolm gladwell speculates that canadian ice hockey players that are born early in the year have an advantage. That means that if you turn 9 on january the 2 nd, you will be playing the whole year with 8yearold colleagues. The first chapter in outliers is about how some canadian hockey players born in the. One story tells of the canadian hockey league and the fascinating statistic that the vast majority of all successful hockey players are born in january, february or march.
In canada, the eligibility cutoff for ageclass hockey programs is jan. The tipping point, blink, outliers, what the dog saw, and david and goliath. In his bestselling book, outliers, malcolm gladwell discusses people who are. A boy who turns ten on jan 2 could be playing against someone who doesnt turn ten for 12 more months and at age 10, a 12 month gap in age is a huge difference in physical maturity. May 19, 2010 from an interview with malcolm gladwell 1.
Roster of the team is presented and pattern of players born in certain months. A young boy has talent as a child, is found by a talent scout, and works hard to rise. The story of success is the third nonfiction book written by malcolm gladwell and published by little, brown and company on november 18, 2008. It is interesting to witness the tackling that occurs between gladwell and many other strong individuals whove tasted success without the need for his methods and techniques. Gladwell explains that, in canada, hockey leagues start when kids. Gladwell actually makes a comment that if you were born after the first few months of the year you might as well forget about ever being a top hockey player in canada. Sociologist who famously called the phenomenon of canadian hockey players being predominately born in the first few months of the year, the matthew effect. Malcolm gladwells outliers argued that extraordinary success. It would one day find itself with twice as many great hockey players. Malcolm gladwell explores the nature of success the star.
This is a central idea to gladwells theory of what produces successful individuals and he begins with the example of outstanding young canadian hockey players. Outliers quotes this is a book about outliers, about men and women who do things that are out of the ordinary. Jul 29, 2009 gladwell explains that, in canada, hockey leagues start when kids are young and the cutoff age for each league is the beginning of january. In one example, gladwell uses the canadian hockey league chl to point out. League will not award calder cup for first time since 1936. At the beginning of the matthew effect the topic changed to the canadian. Your goal is to become a really successful hockey player. Relying on the work of a canadian psychologist who noticed that a. The chapter opens with a story about about two canadian hockey teams who played each other in the 2007 memorial cup hockey championship, the medicine hat tigers and the vancouver giants. The book begins with the observation that a disproportionate number of elite canadian hockey players are born in the earlier months of the calendar year. The result is his new book outliers little, brown, which finds parallels between the beatles, bill gates and canadian hockey players as well as. His answer is that we pay too much attention to what successful people are like and too little attention. But malcolm gladwell, insists that canada is a long way f. Outliers book questions 1 student english 42 45119 coach.
Darren helm of the medicine hats scored on vancouver goalie tyler sexsmith. Aware of his office, the canadian resort appeals to the stories to articulate and forceful arguments. Jun 07, 2011 malcolm gladwell is the author of five new york times bestsellers. According to gladwell, canadian hockey could easily be regarded as a meritocracywealth and family background, after all, do not matter in determining hockey skill. Student english 42 45119 coach pescar 092015 outliers journal writing 1. Birth date and canadian ice hockey in his book outliers. As an example, how would one explain why the best canadian hockey players are most frequently born in the first. They were the two best teams in the chl canadian hockey league. Thousands of canadian boys begin to play the sport at the. Speaking of canadian hockey when my son was 11, he and some of his friends from their youth hockey league in virginia went to hockey camp in canada. There is a general, strong belief that canadian hockey leagues are organised as a meritocracy.
The first case is of the canadian hockey league, where he inadvertently selected. In this stunning new book, malcolm gladwell takes us on an intellectua. I know im late to the party, but it really made me think. In this stunning book, malcolm gladwell takes us on an intellectual journey through the world of outliersthe best and the brightest, the most famous and the. Gladwell starts with the roseto mystery where i thought the book is talking about them and how they are healthy. Nov 22, 2010 the result, gladwell says, is an iron law of canadian hockey. However, gladwell states that common assumptions about merit and commonplace, selfmademan success stories do not accurately explain how success is really attained. May 10, 2012 gladwell begins by illustrating how the vast majority of professional canadian hockey players are born between january and april.
The result, gladwell says, is an iron law of canadian hockey. To support his thesis, he examines why the majority of canadian ice hockey players are born in the first few months of the calendar year, how microsoft co. Outliers are, like almost all the books gladwell, extremely interesting and agile. A surprising fact that illustrates the way that an arbitrary cutoff date for league membership can provide the slightly older i. The book explores the paths of successful people and, in doing so, reveals some startling truths. In this stunning new book, malcolm gladwell takes us on an intellectual journey through the world of outliers the best and the brightest, the most famous and the most successful. However, though they all pour out endless energy to reach the top, thats only half the story. This is because the birthdate cutoff for different levels of youth hockey leagues in canada is january 1st, so youth hockey players who.
Extraordinary achievement is less about talent than it is about opportunity. Thats because the cutoff date for peewee hockey is jan. At the peak of this system is the canadian hockey league, a junior of 17 to 19. Dec 12, 2018 this is particularly prevalent in canadian hockey because it is hard to practice consistently without being in a formal league with assigned ice time. Gladwell opens the chapter with a seemingly innocuous description of a canadian hockey players rise to the top of the sport in canada. Jul 03, 2017 one story tells of the canadian hockey league and the fascinating statistic that the vast majority of all successful hockey players are born in january, february or march. Malcolm gladwell, author of the tipping point and blink. Why malcolm gladwell thinks we have little control over our own.
Because we so profoundly personalize success, we miss opportunities to lift others onto the top rung. The most confusing parts for me were the introduction and the beginning of chapter one. To support his thesis, he examines why the majority of canadian ice hockey players are born in the first. Gladwell has taken an example of canadian hockey league. The canadian hockey league is proud to announce the three finalists for the 201920 chl sportsman of the year award presented by cavendish farms. The first chapter in outliers is about how some canadian hockey. The power of thinking without thinking, has written another masterful, mindbender called outliers. In may, 2007, the medicine hat tigers competed against the vancouver giants for the memorial cup hockey championship game in vancouver. Outliers the introduction and chapters 12 summary and. Aug 18, 2017 gladwell sets the scene to this chapter by painting a picture of the tigers and the giants competing for victory in the memorial league hockey cup the two best teams in the hockey league chock full of the future stars of league hockey.
After all, it was simply stated in the book that it is just a fact that top canadian hockey players are overwhelmingly born in the first 3 months of the year. He is also the cofounder of pushkin industries, an audio content company that produces the podcasts revisionist history, which reconsiders things both overlooked and misunderstood, and broken record, where he, rick rubin, and bruce headlam interview. This is because the birthdate cutoff for different levels of youth hockey leagues in canada is january 1st, so youth hockey players who are born in january. Nov 30, 2008 just imagine, gladwell writes, if canada created another youth hockey league for children born in the second half of the year. This league consists of young men ranging in age from 16 to 20 years old, many of whom go on to become professional hockey players. The term relative age effect rae, also known as birthdate effect or birth date effect, is used to. A closer look at the last decade of chl sportsman of the year winners from 201019. Over decades, he played in a manner of unintended benefits given to those born in the early months of the year, illustrating the role play rules and policies of institutions to favor some over others, although not on purpose.
Why the majority of hockey players in canada are born on the first three months of the year. There are a supermajority of professional canadian hockey players with early birthdays, and a minority with late ones. Because the cutoff date for signing children is january 1, and those born in the first three months have a distinct advantage in age, experience and size in relation to. This is a book about outliers, the people who do things above the ordinary. Gladwell describes the complex system of amateur hockey leagues that are spread out across canada. Mozart, and the best players in the canadian hockey league, showing they all achieved mastery of their art after about 10,000 hours of practice, regardless of the talents they may have been born with. He even gives his interpretation of why asians are so good at maths. In canada the eligibility cutoff for ageclass is jan 1. But how are the best players chosen for the national team.
Coach of the 2007 vancouver giants hockey team, winners of the memorial cup. Jan 07, 2009 after all, it was simply stated in the book that it is just a fact that top canadian hockey players are overwhelmingly born in the first 3 months of the year. One of the two finest teams in the canadian hockey league. Do you know of any junior sports leagues that are trying to change the way. The reason behind this is that since youth hockey leagues determine. This produces a dynamic where the roster composition of any elite canadian hockey team is roughly 40% players born in januarymarch, 30% born between apriljune, 20% between julyseptember and 10. These were the future stars of the sport seventeen, eighteen, and. Canada also takes hockey really seriously, so coaches start streaming. Litcharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in outliers, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work. If you are born on january 1, you play hockey with kids born the same year as you, through december 31. The story of success by malcolm gladwell penguin books 2008. Son of an american president, brother of an american president, and grandson of a wealthy wall street banker and a u.
In his recent bestseller, outliers, native son malcolm gladwell claims that if a. In outliers, gladwell examines the factors that contribute to high levels of success. Outliers is at once gladwells least and most ambitious book. Birth date and canadian ice hockey in his book out. As engaging as this book can be, outliers has its flaws. Outliers pdf the story of success in this stunning new book, malcolm gladwell takes us on an intellectual journey through the world of outliers the best and the brightest, the most famous and the most successful. Gladwell describes then the canadian hockey system. Malcolm gladwells new book, outliers, explains why some success in sports. The league was for players between 17 and 20 years old. Everyone had assumption all successful players succeeded because they were talented and worked hard. The story of success malcolm gladwell in this provocative and inspiring book, malcolm gladwell examines everyone from business giants to scientific geniuses, sports stars to musicians, and reveals what they have in common.
In the mid1980s he studied players in the western hockey league. Gladwell centers on a realworld example in which almost all of the players who had been selected for a canadian hockey league team had birthdays in the first four months of the year. Theyre skilled and fit, and most become professionals. These two teams were the best in the canadian hockey league, which in turn is the best junior hockey league anywhere. Gladwell sets the scene to this chapter by painting a picture of the tigers and the giants competing for victory in the memorial league hockey cup the two best teams in the hockey league chock full of the future stars of league hockey. In the canadian all star junior hockey league the surest ticket to the nhl the majority of the players on the winning team were born in january, february, or march. The reference is to a verse in the book of matthew in the bible that can be summarized as those who have much will get even more, while those who have little will lose even that small amount. Double the number of junior hockey leaguessome for kids born in the first half of the year. Here is the player roster of the 2007 medicine hat tigers.
Past winners of sportsman of the year presented by cavendish farms. You should also know that in canada the eligibility cutoff for ageclass is january 1 st. To support his thesis, he examines why the majority of canadian ice hockey. He then goes on to say that those with the early birthdays are the outliers that go on to achieve hockey success later in life.
One of the first to research relative age in canadian hockey players was. The first chapter of the section is entitled the matthew effect. Gladwell begins by illustrating how the vast majority of professional canadian hockey players are born between january and april. Mano bliznak scored first for vancouver in the second period. This is because the birthdate cutoff for different levels of youth hockey leagues in canada is january 1st,so youth hockey players who are born in january and february are slightly. Theyre fit and talented, and many turn professional. Unfortunately, though, gibbs, jarvis, and dufurs work suggests the outliers story is wrong or, at least, overblown in relation to canadian junior hockey players. Malcolm gladwell and canadian hockey data sap analytics cloud. This is a book about outliers, about men and women who do things that are out of the. Gladwell notes the preponderance of winter birthdays in the canadian hockey league. Jun 01, 2016 gladwell has taken an example of canadian hockey league. After checking out malcolms gladwells new book, outliers, and his.
Lets assume that you want to join the junior canadian hockey league. Chapter 1 of malcolm gladwells outliers opens with a discussion of a canadian hockey game, a game for the memorial cup championships. Because in canada, elite hockey teams have tryouts at the age of 10, and the age cutoff is. Something like 98% of canadian junior players came up through the canadian system 1980pres.
Nov 17, 2008 gladwell notes the preponderance of winter birthdays in the canadian hockey league. The reason behind this is that since youth hockey leagues determine eligibility by the calendar year, children born on january 1 play in the same league as those born on december 31 in the. After checking out malcolms gladwells new book, outliers, and his explanation of why canadian hockey players born early in the year have a big advantage, we conducted a little study. One spring day in 2007 the two finest teams in the canadian hockey league met in the final of the memorial cup.
1091 51 701 1442 1482 1390 801 42 585 633 847 1541 764 1202 950 1310 1400 985 788 659 1212 1529 30 199 778 441 833 387 461 348 1209 1022 1255 722